# I Posted the Same Short Video on 6 Platforms. Here's Where It Got Views.

> Which platform is best for short videos? I post every Boom Optimize video to Instagram, YouTube Shorts, TikTok and more, and share the real view counts here.

- URL: https://boomoptimize.com/articles/short-video-cross-posting-results
- Author: Rob P. (https://boomoptimize.com/about)
- Published: 2026-11-16
- Category: Social Media & LinkedIn
- Tools covered: Repurpose.io

## Quick answer

In my first test, the same 21-second video got 419 views on YouTube Shorts, 111 on TikTok and 8 on Instagram in its first few hours. That's one video on brand-new accounts, so it's an early signal, not a rule. I'm adding every new video and updating these numbers as the data grows.

## Key takeaways

- Same video, same caption, same day: YouTube Shorts 419 views, TikTok 111, Instagram 8 after a few hours.
- All three accounts were brand new, so this is an early read, not a final answer.
- Instagram's comment count includes my auto-replies, so it overstates real comments.
- Posting once and letting a tool copy the video costs almost no extra time.
- I'll add Facebook, Threads, Pinterest and X numbers once their stats are connected.

I post every Boom Optimize video once, on Instagram, and a tool copies it to YouTube Shorts, TikTok, Facebook, Threads, Pinterest and X. Same video, same caption, same day. That makes it a clean test of a question every small business asks: which platform is actually worth posting short videos on?

This page shares the real numbers. It starts small, with my very first video, and I'm adding every new one as the data comes in.

## How I'm running the test

The setup is the same for every video:

1. I post the video on Instagram at a set time.
2. [Repurpose.io](https://boomoptimize.com/tools/repurpose) copies it to the other platforms, usually within 20 to 30 minutes, with no watermark. (Here's [how that setup works](https://boomoptimize.com/articles/post-to-all-social-media-at-once).)
3. Every morning, a job reads each platform's view, like, comment, share and save counts and saves them.
4. I compare lifetime totals for the same video across platforms.

What I'm not doing: paying for ads, buying views, or changing the video per app. The goal is to see what each platform does with the exact same post.

## What did the first video get on each platform?

The first video was a 21-second Reel about AI receptionists, the "Stop answering your own phone" video. It went up on November 16, 2026. These numbers were read about four hours after it posted.

| Platform | Views | Likes | Comments | Shares | Saves |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| YouTube Shorts | 419 | 3 | 1 | not reported | not reported |
| TikTok | 111 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| Instagram Reels | 8 | 0 | 8 | 0 | 0 |
| Facebook, Threads, Pinterest, X | not measured yet | | | | |

YouTube Shorts got about 78% of all the views I could measure. TikTok got most of the rest. Instagram, where the video was posted first, got the fewest.

### A note on Instagram's comments

Instagram shows 8 comments, the most of any platform. That number needs context. Every comment with the video's keyword triggers an automatic DM and a short public reply from my account, and Instagram counts those replies as comments too. The cleaner number: 4 people got the DM on day one. Here's [the comment-to-DM setup I use](https://boomoptimize.com/articles/manychat-alternative).

## Why did YouTube Shorts win the first round?

I can't see inside any platform's ranking, so I won't pretend to know. Here's what I can say for sure:

- All three accounts were brand new, with almost no followers anywhere.
- Instagram also reported the video reached 4 accounts, so it was barely shown at all at first.
- YouTube and TikTok put it in front of hundreds of people within hours, with no followers to start from.

So the early lesson is narrow: for a new account, YouTube Shorts and TikTok seem to hand out first views more freely than Instagram. Whether that holds after 30, 60 or 100 videos is exactly what this page will track.

## What are the limits of this test?

Be careful with these numbers. Real limits:

- **One video so far.** One video can't tell you much on its own. A bad hook, a good hook or posting time can swing one result.
- **A few hours of data.** Short videos often keep picking up views for days.
- **New accounts.** An account with an audience behaves differently.
- **Different definitions.** Each app counts a "view" its own way, so treat them as rough comparisons, not exact ones.
- **Four platforms not measured yet.** Facebook, Threads, Pinterest and X get the video too, but I haven't connected their stats.

## Is it worth posting the same video everywhere?

For a small business, yes, as long as it costs you no extra work. Making the video is the expensive part. Copying it to five more apps is close to free once a tool does it, and you learn where your audience actually watches.

A few things I've learned from running it:

1. **Put your call to action in the video, not only the caption.** Some apps cut long captions short.
2. **Use one caption that works everywhere.** No "link in bio" wording that only fits one app.
3. **Give people a link that works on every app.** My comment-word DMs only work on Instagram, so the video also says to get the link from my site.

One downside of auto-posting: a tool copies exactly what you give it. When X's 280-character limit cut my captions short, the end of the caption, including my disclosure line, got dropped. I moved the important lines to the top.

## How can you run this test for your own business?

You don't need a dashboard to start. A spreadsheet works:

1. Make one short video you'd post anyway, under 30 seconds, with captions burned in.
2. Post it on Instagram, YouTube Shorts and TikTok on the same day, with the same caption. Do it by hand or with a posting tool.
3. Write down each app's views, likes and comments 24 hours later, then again after 7 days.
4. Repeat for 10 videos before you decide anything. One video is noise; ten start to show a pattern.
5. Put more effort into the app that keeps winning, but keep posting the copies elsewhere. It's nearly free.

## Bottom line

After the first video, YouTube Shorts led with 419 views, TikTok had 111, and Instagram had 8, on brand-new accounts, a few hours in. That's a signal, not a verdict. If you're choosing where to post, don't pick one app on a hunch: post the same video everywhere for a month and let the numbers decide. I'm doing exactly that, and I'll keep this page updated with every video I add.

## Frequently asked questions

### Which platform is best for short videos?

In my first test, YouTube Shorts got the most views by far, then TikTok, then Instagram. It was one video on new accounts, so test your own. Posting the same video everywhere is the cheapest way to find out where your audience is.

### Should I post the same video on TikTok, Reels and YouTube Shorts?

I do, with the same caption, and so far each app counts it as its own post. A tool like Repurpose.io copies the video after you post it once. Remove any other app's watermark first; Instagram has said it shows Reels with other apps' watermarks less.

### Why did my Reel get so few views on Instagram?

I can't see Instagram's ranking, so I can't say for sure. My account was brand new with almost no followers, and a new account starts with little reach. I'm tracking whether it changes as the account posts more.

### How do you track views across platforms?

A daily job reads each platform's numbers every morning and saves them, so I can see the change from day to day. Instagram's come from its owner insights, YouTube's from the YouTube Data API, and TikTok's from its public video stats.

### Does cross-posting hurt reach?

I haven't seen evidence of that in my numbers so far, but one video can't prove it either way. I'll update this page as more videos come in.
